The Gold Behind The Green
CNN-IBN, a leading TV channel in India recently carried this story about young children being recruited into the communist guerilla army in Colombia.
Read story and watch video here
As an Indian living in Bogota, I feel compelled to respond to this story.
This video definitely has the dirtiest shade of grey to it, reality usually has that shade. More importantly, this is not an isolated story. Dozens of guerilla groups operate from within the dense jungles of the North and till date, continue to extort, kidnap, pillage, rape and harvest (yes, cocaine). That they are protecting the country from the right-wing, is a fallacy. What started as a genuine ideological rebellion decades ago by the guerillas turned into a seperatist movement and then to a time today .. where their only motive is to instill a fear in the people of Colombia and thus send out a signal to the forces - that they exist. And of course, to flourish their illicit but extremely lucrative harvest. Drug money can fund global wars, maintaining an army uses up their small change.
Coutries around Latin America in general (and El Salvador in specific) have lost their children to similar guerilla movements. Young children are to them what young children are to the world - fearless, idealistic. Not to mention .. physically fit enough to assemble and fire an AK-47 and naive enough to look beyond the mortal view of death.
The 'third wave' guerillas are a menace to Colombia and a menace to mankind. I say mankind because it is said that more than 50% of narco movement across the world can be routed back to guerilla owned plantations in Colombia. They grow the damn Coke, they therefore perpetuate absolutely every crime associated with it.
BUT, this is not the point of my response really. It pains many many Colombians (like it pains some foreigners who live here) that this is the ONLY story the world knows of Colombia.
I've only spent three months here, but I've felt as safe in Colombia as I have in my own country. Come to think of it, any city in India could very easily feel as safe or as dangerous as any other city in the world that you could dream of, or dread!
I know people here whose parents, relatives and friends have been kidnapped and .. killed. Recently, a friend's younger brother was kidnapped .. exactly 6 years after his father was. It has been confirmed that both of them are alive and are being well taken care of, but the family might never seen them again.
Shocking.
Now .. There is a little town in Andhra Pradesh (a state in Southern India) called Nalgonda, where an elaborate seperatist rebellion has been in motion for years. The Naxalites in this town can boast of crimes far more attrocious. I was in Nalgonda when I was 12 years old, and I saw with my very own eyes a man running a constable down and murdering him. A friend of my brother saw his father being shot at and killed in the same town. Women (especially foreigners) feel no safer in Delhi and Mumbai than I do, walking alone through an unguarded Colombian forest. Same danger, different demons.
This is a TINY sample of the India we don't like to talk about.
But it would pain, frustrate and throw us into denial mode if this was the only India that the world knew. Thankfully we have the IT companies, the BSE and Bollywood to account for stories more newsworthy in the international domain.
So, consider this of Colombia ..
1. The President of Colombia, Sr. Alvaro Uribe has single handedly scripted what can possibly be viewed as the most dramatic socio-political turnaround in the history of the world and it's great democracies. This democracy is over 150 years old and has been ridden with corruption and guerilla effected terror. In the last 4 years, he has re-integrated tens of thousands of terrorists into mainstream society, reduced the number of coca hectares by half and given 44 million people a freedom they never knew existed .. the freedom to drive a car 10 hours any direction in the country. He has had his fair share of critics, but I am not aware of an elected head of state who enjoys the support of his country a) from across it's social strata and b) FOR THE RIGHT REASONS. The World could learn from this democracy.
2. The country of Colombia is one of the most beautiful countries in the world. The fact that is has the highest per-capita bio-diversity in the world is more than just a fact. Snow-capped mountain ranges, deserts, beaches, rainforests, volcanoes .. really, its a sight to see! It is a magnificent country and happiness is a way of life here.
Do watch this video before reading further ..
The world could cut this country some slack. Colombians find it really hard to get visas to travel (Indians have it easier in comparison!) and the country is generally perceived as being full of drug addicts and sand & thorn landscapes (think Blow and Mr.&Mrs. Smith, 2 decent movies no doubt.)
It is a beautiful country with a fabulous heritage and history. It's people are amongst the happiest and the most hospitable you will find. In Colombia live some of the hottest women on the planet :) and no, Colombians can't buy cocaine at the local department store (people wonder if Indians were taught the Kamasutra at school)
I come to my point, finally! ...
I don't really intend for this story to highlight what I dislike about my own country or why I think Colombia is so cool. I am proud to be an Indian and want to spend the most part of my productive life there and really, I am in Colombia for only a year.
This story is really an attempt to highlight how people's perceptions of a country, of a culture, of a religion or of an individual are fashioned not by what they know, but by what they don't.
Read story and watch video here
As an Indian living in Bogota, I feel compelled to respond to this story.
This video definitely has the dirtiest shade of grey to it, reality usually has that shade. More importantly, this is not an isolated story. Dozens of guerilla groups operate from within the dense jungles of the North and till date, continue to extort, kidnap, pillage, rape and harvest (yes, cocaine). That they are protecting the country from the right-wing, is a fallacy. What started as a genuine ideological rebellion decades ago by the guerillas turned into a seperatist movement and then to a time today .. where their only motive is to instill a fear in the people of Colombia and thus send out a signal to the forces - that they exist. And of course, to flourish their illicit but extremely lucrative harvest. Drug money can fund global wars, maintaining an army uses up their small change.
Coutries around Latin America in general (and El Salvador in specific) have lost their children to similar guerilla movements. Young children are to them what young children are to the world - fearless, idealistic. Not to mention .. physically fit enough to assemble and fire an AK-47 and naive enough to look beyond the mortal view of death.
The 'third wave' guerillas are a menace to Colombia and a menace to mankind. I say mankind because it is said that more than 50% of narco movement across the world can be routed back to guerilla owned plantations in Colombia. They grow the damn Coke, they therefore perpetuate absolutely every crime associated with it.
BUT, this is not the point of my response really. It pains many many Colombians (like it pains some foreigners who live here) that this is the ONLY story the world knows of Colombia.
I've only spent three months here, but I've felt as safe in Colombia as I have in my own country. Come to think of it, any city in India could very easily feel as safe or as dangerous as any other city in the world that you could dream of, or dread!
I know people here whose parents, relatives and friends have been kidnapped and .. killed. Recently, a friend's younger brother was kidnapped .. exactly 6 years after his father was. It has been confirmed that both of them are alive and are being well taken care of, but the family might never seen them again.
Shocking.
Now .. There is a little town in Andhra Pradesh (a state in Southern India) called Nalgonda, where an elaborate seperatist rebellion has been in motion for years. The Naxalites in this town can boast of crimes far more attrocious. I was in Nalgonda when I was 12 years old, and I saw with my very own eyes a man running a constable down and murdering him. A friend of my brother saw his father being shot at and killed in the same town. Women (especially foreigners) feel no safer in Delhi and Mumbai than I do, walking alone through an unguarded Colombian forest. Same danger, different demons.
This is a TINY sample of the India we don't like to talk about.
But it would pain, frustrate and throw us into denial mode if this was the only India that the world knew. Thankfully we have the IT companies, the BSE and Bollywood to account for stories more newsworthy in the international domain.
So, consider this of Colombia ..
1. The President of Colombia, Sr. Alvaro Uribe has single handedly scripted what can possibly be viewed as the most dramatic socio-political turnaround in the history of the world and it's great democracies. This democracy is over 150 years old and has been ridden with corruption and guerilla effected terror. In the last 4 years, he has re-integrated tens of thousands of terrorists into mainstream society, reduced the number of coca hectares by half and given 44 million people a freedom they never knew existed .. the freedom to drive a car 10 hours any direction in the country. He has had his fair share of critics, but I am not aware of an elected head of state who enjoys the support of his country a) from across it's social strata and b) FOR THE RIGHT REASONS. The World could learn from this democracy.
2. The country of Colombia is one of the most beautiful countries in the world. The fact that is has the highest per-capita bio-diversity in the world is more than just a fact. Snow-capped mountain ranges, deserts, beaches, rainforests, volcanoes .. really, its a sight to see! It is a magnificent country and happiness is a way of life here.
Do watch this video before reading further ..
The world could cut this country some slack. Colombians find it really hard to get visas to travel (Indians have it easier in comparison!) and the country is generally perceived as being full of drug addicts and sand & thorn landscapes (think Blow and Mr.&Mrs. Smith, 2 decent movies no doubt.)
It is a beautiful country with a fabulous heritage and history. It's people are amongst the happiest and the most hospitable you will find. In Colombia live some of the hottest women on the planet :) and no, Colombians can't buy cocaine at the local department store (people wonder if Indians were taught the Kamasutra at school)
I come to my point, finally! ...
I don't really intend for this story to highlight what I dislike about my own country or why I think Colombia is so cool. I am proud to be an Indian and want to spend the most part of my productive life there and really, I am in Colombia for only a year.
This story is really an attempt to highlight how people's perceptions of a country, of a culture, of a religion or of an individual are fashioned not by what they know, but by what they don't.
18 Comments:
Dandy: great insights on Columbia. One inevitably tends to become passionate about the place where one lives..especially us AIESEC'ers. However, I have to say your comment about Indian democracy wasn't entirely fair:
1. Graft exists at every level, so don't say you're disgusted with Indian corruption. Its an evil every political system has to fight.
2. You say Indian democracy is not effective. I take strong exception to that statement. You talk about the reservation debate and coalition politics...BUT here you need to understand that these are both issues that have come about BECAUSE fundamentally, India is one of the strongest democracies ever to have existed, with a judiciary completely independent of the political system. It is because we are a vibrant democracy that people are able to protest for their cause in such an open manner. Reservations have come about because of leftists; and leftists are IN POWER because the electorate has put them there, not because of some political manipulation. So my point is that yes Indian democracy has several flaws but fundamentally, its still healthy & strong so lets not knock Indian democracy without examining all the angles.
By Abs, at 7:15 AM
This post has been removed by a blog administrator.
By Abs, at 7:16 AM
Oh and just re read your post and saw the bit about pinch criticism, not sure what that is :-) but the above post wasn't an angry retort. It was an honest reflection of the facts as they are on the ground today in India. People are being empowered like nobody's business...and that's what makes me sing, "pintarse la cara, color esperanza" :-)
By Abs, at 7:28 AM
Totally agree with you there. But a statement like that warrants a better explanation and I'll probably do that in another post. In fact, I will delete the following lines because it is not at all the focus of my story.
"India, largest democracy in the world? Yes. But effective democracy? Most certainly not. The recent reservation debate, the ridiculous coalition politics, the everyday stories of corruption at every level and certain other developments have, in my mind, rendered our democracy incapable of action. (This statement is sure to invoke pinch criticism, I'll be glad to hear it)"
y, todo bien otherwise?
By dhanur, at 9:32 AM
thanks for writting something like this. you could say the same about any country where the media exports their own images of the country. being an american in egypt you really get to see that side of things as well.
comombia is #2 on my list to travel next.
thanks again
By kaitlin (papita), at 2:26 PM
You are so right!!
Nothing is black or white but unfortunately people often don't want to see the other side. It's so much easier to think f.e. every Iranian is a terrorist.
That?s why it is so important to go abroad and experience how the country, culture, people really is,
like in your case with Columbia
By alex, at 2:45 PM
You can't be more right.
Being from a conflictive country (El Salvador) where people still asks me "hey how is the war over there?" when war was over 14 years ago, its really easy to understand the problem underlying other countries that face similar realities.
After El Salvador, I could say Colombia is definitely my favorite country and I put my efforts when advicingng people that want to travel to visit Colombia, I go there at least once a year and everytime I fall more in love with it.
It's unfair to judge a country from what the media says. Media tends to destroy opinions instead of constructing good ones when it comes to situations like this. Haha Probably except E! Entertainment television :P
By beatriz guillen, at 4:10 PM
loved your post. I travelled to Colombia to visit friends about a year and a half ago. Everyone thought I'm crazy to travel there, but I had the best time and saw a truly beautiful country. I'll never forget our lunch at lago di Tota, our trip to the coffee region or our visit to Cartagena and the wonderful beaches there. Unfortunately this side of Colombia is not what's talked about most in the world. I truly hope Uribe will be able to continue what he's doing to improve the situation in Colombia to a degree that all the beautiful sides of this country will take over the news...
By simi, at 4:51 PM
Nice post Dandy.
Child soldiers are a sick part of society that most people haven't even heard about. Africa & South Asia too have many wars being fought by children who if only they had been born in a different time, might have been facing each other off on a soccer field instead.
By pierre, at 7:54 PM
And thats exactly the problem that Africa suffers from. The media only concentrates on the hunger, the corruption, AIDS, malaria, poverty...and nothing else. This place is beautiful and the people are lovely. BBC needs to take its cameras to the Vic falls!
Good post. You should really write more.
By Shikha, at 5:57 AM
Boss, you convinced me to make a trip to Columbia (sometime).. it'll happen!
You should really write more!
By Prabs, at 11:46 AM
Your an awsome writer man..
I hope there are more great posts
like this one to come
I met you at IC 2005 but I'm sure you met a lot of people there :)
I am on an MC in Cameroon now...
Good that your rockin the world....
HAve fun
Juanita
By Life is beautiful, at 2:36 PM
dude, nice post and all that but just cause you got caught trafficking doesn't mean you had to come up with this. Your true friends will still be true friends!
- Friend
By Anonymous, at 5:06 AM
hahahahahaha lol sidp:)
By chitgo, at 3:50 AM
hey, I really liked your article. I know it touches on political issues, but I just want to applaud you on your spirit as a traveller, being able to retain an open mind and absorbing a country and its people so wholly and passionately into your blood. Well done.
By Ruhi, at 2:17 AM
Amazing post. Colombia is unlike anywhere else in this world. Keep spreading the word to anyone and everyone you know. Knowledge is a powerful thing. Don't be afraid to challenge perspectives, both yours and those of people you know.
I fell in love with the magic of Colombian culture 6 months ago when I first visited the country for AXLDS. I'm a trainee in Barranquilla right now, and constantly struggle to find the right words to describe the amazing reality of Colombia - the reality that the media doesn't show - to everyone back home.
colombia es pasion, no?
By SarahEliz, at 11:33 PM
"This story is really an attempt to highlight how people's perceptions of a country, of a culture, of a religion or of an individual are fashioned not by what they know, but by what they don't."
BRAVO!!
By Anonymous, at 12:57 PM
We visit your blog and have been awhile, thank you
By Té la mà Maria, at 5:31 AM
Post a Comment
<< Home